NOname
Întrebare recomandată | NOname a întrebat:

O întrebare, pe care este bine să ne-o punem periodic cu toţii: Când vine vorba de sfârşit, va fi mai puţină suferinţă în lume, pentru că ai trăit sau pentru că ai murit?
Sau o variantă similară: Când vei înceta din viaţă, va fi mai multă suferinţă în lume sau mai puţină?

Răspuns Câştigător
| Leocerba a răspuns:

O stii pe Tereza Cremisi?
Nici eu.
Stiu insa o povestioara in care Cioran a fost implicat. O doamna, intr-un moment de angoasa, se intalneste in drumul ei catre birou cu Cioran. Cioran mergea sa-si cumpere niste rosii, cre` ca. Si doamna incepe sa i se planga lui Cioran ca poate si-a ratat viata, toata ziua la acelasi birou, si daca nu si-a ratat-o inca, poate ca o sa si-o rateze in curand. Cioran, excedat, ridicand ochii spre cer, ii spune doamnei "Asculta, cucoana, Parisul e totusi un loc excelent unde sa-ti ratezi viata, nu crezi?"

Asa zic si eu in fata intrebarii tale, nu stiu daca va fi mai putina sau mai multa suferinta pentru ca am trait sau pentru ca am murit dar ce pot eu sa fac cat inca sunt vie e sa fac lumea un loc excelent in care sa merite sa suferi.
laughing
( doamna angoasata era cred Teresa Cremisi si cred ca a facut cateva lucruri remarcabile, sau o sa le faca in curand )

159 răspunsuri:
NOname
| NOname explică (pentru Arthiom):

Sunt mai multe tipuri de sclavi.

Cert este, că atunci când pui apetitul tău mai presus decât suferinţa unui animal nevinovat, decât binele lui, când conştientizezi că e greşit să torturezi şi să omori (sau să comanzi asta, plătind), dar tot o faci, neputându-te stăpâni, nu eşti liber, eşti prizonierul viciilor tale cele mai atroce.

NOname
| NOname explică:

Beyond Carnism and toward Rational, Authentic Food Choices | Melanie Joy | TEDxMünchen
http://youtu.be/o0VrZPBskpg

| Seven07 a răspuns:

Ok, aici probabil o sa fiu considerat psihopat dar e ok, tind sa cred ca un raspuns total corect nu exista deoarece... well, poate sa fie si alba si neagra daca ma intelegi. Cand vei inceta din viata... nu vei mai avea vreun sentiment, nu te mai doare, nu iubesti, nu urasti, nimic. Deci mai multa suferinta? Gandind ipotetic, mor mii, sute de mii de oameni zilnic numai din razboaie, copilasi, chiar inocenti, dar voi simtiti vreo suferinta? Nu cred, eu nu simt si care zice ca e traumatizat de mortii din Africa e un mincinos notoriu. Apoi, este perfect legal sa ucidem, avortul, oamenii ucid alti oameni dinainte sa ii aduca, simtiti voi *lumea* vreo suferinta? Nu! Deci in concluzie, nu exista suferinta,"cei dragi" nu sufera, este o manifestare instinctiva a unor oameni slabi si aroganti. Stim toti care este ciclul vietii, te nasti, traiesti, mori, ca ii vezi bocind si urland, asta e pentru "ce zice lumea care vede " dar nu e chiar asa. Poate sunt eu insensibil si putin psihopat, dar eu consider ca infernul e aici, si va disparea suferinta din lume doar cand vor disparea oamenii! TOTI!

| ALGator a răspuns (pentru NOname):

Ar trebui sa incep prin a sterge toate raspunsurile mele pentru ca erau in afara de subiect. Inteleg ca scopul intrebarii era altul.

Nu imi este straina problema tratarii demne a animalelor de catre noi. Dar nu pot sa spun ca am ajuns la un raspuns care sa impace cit de cit si alte aspecte.
Mentinindu-ma strict la intrebare, dupa ca dispar cota mea de carne va transferata altcuiva. Eventual, prin trecerea timpului si cistigarea de teren a unei alte doctrine, mentalitati, va scade numarul celor care consuma carne. Cu alte cuvinte, momentan nu cred ca disparitia mea va reduce suferinta animalelor.

As mai sugera ca o abordare mai solida a subiectului (,,durabila", cum se spune acum) din partea cuiva, ar presupune documentarea la sursa, nu (numai) prin intermediul selectiei facute de partizanii cauzei.
Istorie, filosofie, medicina (partea care priveste alimentatia), etologie, legi si morala. A te documenta nu dureaza infinit de mult, dar totusi poate fi peste puterile (timp sau intelegere) unora.
Mi se pare de dorit sa se faca aceasta documentare sine ira et studio. Saitul facebook citat are dupa parerea mea o problema, aceea ca face apel foarte mult la sentimente prezentind in primul rind informatia spectaculoasa. Ar fi de rumegat la rece, pentru ca oricum nu sint sanse ca problema sa fie rezolvata mîine. Mai bine aleasa o cale,,durabila", atingind un rezultat nu la pastele cailor, si construita pe baze pe care o categorie mai larga de oameni sa le poata intelege si sa le fie mai greu de contraargumentat.
Dupa acest,, ocol" de documentare si aprofundare impartiala ar rezulta mai mai limpede daca ceeace Melanie Joy numeste,, Authentic" (cum ar spune turcul,,, sadea") se confirma.
S-ar putea de exemplu, sa constatam, in urma reflectiilor, ca ca ceeace este autentic pentru noi oamenii nu convine altor conlocuitori ai planetei, dar ca, in ciuda acestui fapt, chiar dorim, gasim ca e in interesul nostru etc sa adoptam aceasta abordare. Nu ar fi primul lucru la care indivizii renunta in favoarea unei cauze comune, asa ca de ce nu?
Dar daca e asa, sa nu prezentam motivatia noastra ca fiind alta doar de dragul rationamentului.

AUTÉNTIC adj. 1. v. adevărat. 2. v. veritabil. 3. adevărat, curat, nefalsificat, original, veritabil. (Artă ~.) 4. bun, curat, veritabil,

Personal sunt pentru o tratare cu minimum de interventie si agresiune, cu respect, a mediului (urban, natural, aici incluzind bineinteles ceeace e viu, mai ales regnul animal).

| ALGator a răspuns (pentru ALGator):

Un exemplu: bun sau rau... Nu vreau sa insinuez ca tocmai raspunsul citat de mine mai jos e singurul adevarat. Exista probabil sute de mii de astfel de pareri, multe din ele batindu-se cap in cap, unele mai intelepte, altele mai putin. Am citat doar pe una cu simplu scop,, pedagogic".

"As a vegetarian who returned to meat-eating, I find the question "Is meat-eating ethical?" one that is in my head and heart constantly. The reasons I became a vegetarian, then a vegan and then again a conscientious meat-eater were all ethical."

http://www.nytimes.com/......-meat.html

NOname
| NOname explică:

"A NEW BORN CHILD IS THROWN IN THE MIDDLE OF A DEN OF THIEVES, that have already taken them from their mother to steal their milk and now will be bidding to forcibly confine him in a crate for months and steal his flesh and body, for money. you must realize that all products that come from animals harm them and are not necessary for our survival. WE HAVE NO RIGHT TO MAKE THESE CHILDREN SUFFER."

http://www.facebook.com/......706627459/

NOname
| NOname explică:

"THE WALL OF EXCUSES & JUSTIFICATIONS NEEDS TO COME DOWN. the old murder/suicide paradigm is wearing thin and harming us all, even those addicted to it, know they do not have a leg to stand on, it is hard to reach a hand out to those that are okay with cutting off the legs of other beings, to eat them, but we must try. the animals depend on us. we need to show others their excuses do not hold water...VEGANISM IS THE ONLY VIABLE AND COMPASSIONATE FUTURE."

http://www.facebook.com/......833289213/

NOname
| NOname explică:

"WHEN THE TABLES ARE TURNED AND YOU ARE THE ONE THAT IS THE "FARM' ANIMAL, being cut apart, for your body parts, this idea of being "sacrificed" to be food or trinkets, for others, seems a little barbaric and silly, right? empathy seems to only come, when we have also been treated with disdain, and cruelty. it does not have to go this far. THINK WITH COMPASSION, THINK VEGAN!"

http://www.facebook.com/......569961106/

NOname
| NOname explică:

"THE STORY BEHIND THE IGNORING OF THIS CRY FOR HELP IS HEARTBREAKING. this needy kitten approached a hiker in Vietnam to rescue them, as they could not fend for themselves, he walked away. their excuse is they let nature take "it's" course, but you are a part of nature, and could have helped is our rebuttal. if you can stop the suffering of any animal, in any way, please do! WE ARE THE EQUALIZERS, TO THE INDIFFERENCE."

http://www.facebook.com/......749958788/

NOname
| NOname explică:

"WE MUST MAKE IT SO EVERYONE UNDERSTANDS ALL ANIMALS ARE POTENTIAL FRIENDS and none are meant to be our "food", whether it is online, on the streets or in your homes or by watching documentaries with your friends and family, we must awaken all the others concerning the Holocaust of these innocent souls, and only then can they make an educated decision to continue in this circle of death. check out the links below, to see that we are making a difference. we must make it so SLAUGHTERHOUSES HAVE GLASS WALLS AND ALL SEE WHAT THEY SUPPORT."

http://www.facebook.com/......633294633/

NOname
| NOname explică:

"THE TERRORISM PIGS GO THROUGH BECAUSE YOU ARE A BACON JUNKIE, means there is a victim here, because of your addiction, so that makes it a crime, and we will not sit back and allow you to harm the innocent, for a taste sensation. vegans are your wake up call. your choices are harming others if you eat animals, so this is everyone's business. EATING MEAT & DAIRY IS NOT A "PERSONAL" CHOICE!"

http://www.facebook.com/......879961575/

NOname
| NOname explică:

"WHY WOULD "GOD" MAKE US OF MEAT, IF WE ARE NOT MEANT TO BE EATEN? this idea so many use that animals are here for us to use and abuse...is human arrogance and greed. we do not need to eat any animals and only 25% of animals eat others. if we did not have ways to protect ourselves, they would eat us, too. IF YOU WANT COMPASSION, GIVE COMPASSION!"

http://www.facebook.com/......579966405/

NOname
| NOname explică:

"THE HORRIFIED LOOK ON THIS HELPLESS CHILD'S FACE, SHOULD BE ENOUGH to make you stop eating any "food" that comes from their bodies or is stolen from them. what the procedure is, is not important. as all of it is not needed, and traumatizing. it is all being done, because of our addiction to taste sensations. eating meat is not needed, and, as a matter fact, it does more harm, than good...to you, the animals, and the planet. your money pays for this terrorism, when you buy the carnage they are peddling. HELP END ANIMAL TERRORISM, LIVE AS A VEGAN!"

http://www.facebook.com/......866663843/

NOname
| NOname explică:

"GRAINS ARE BEING GROWN IN AFRICA AND SENT TO THE USA, so the "farm" slaves there can be fattened up to be slaughtered as "burgers", at the rate of 14 pounds of plant food, for every pound of meat and 2000 gallons of water. and the cows, pigs and chickens are born with a due date over their heads, all for money. and feeding these children will not bring anyone money. check out the Philip Wollen speech below, that this quote is from and realize veganism is good for all! to FIGHT FAMINE, GET MEAT OFF THE MENU!"

http://www.facebook.com/......426662987/

NOname
| NOname explică:

"MEAT AND DAIRY IS THE REASON WE HAVE SO MANY STARVING and it is the reason we have so many health issues and the planet is losing so much of its resources and rainforests and it is all harming the biosphere, too...and all the while, we are killing close to 70 billion animals yearly, to die early from eating them ourselves. links are below, for those that can handle the truth. WHAT PART OF BEING VEGAN DOES NOT MAKE SENSE?"

http://www.facebook.com/......393330157/

NOname
| NOname explică:

"THIS IS HOW THEY BREED BABY LAMBS, TO BE SLAUGHTERED. artificial insemination is easier for the sadistic workers, but very painful for the ewes. did you actually think they had a date night? in those hell hole, death camps! these animals are just machines to those that make money from their suffering. do not buy wool, leather, fur, meat, dairy or any animal products! BY VEGAN, SO NOBODY GETS HURT!"

http://www.facebook.com/......776664152/

NOname
| NOname explică:

"WHY DO THE REAL COMPASSIONATE AND KIND MEN HAVE TO HIDE? while the barbaric and real animal terrorists are seen as celebrities? if we are ever to call ourselves a civilized society, we must support the k-ind and compassionate and stop celebrating the wicked, weak and murderous. LONG LIVE ALF, THE FREEDOM FIGHTERS!"

http://www.facebook.com/......073330989/

NOname
| NOname explică:

"THESE ABUSED SOULS NEED THE STRONG AND DECENT HUMAN SOULS, to speak for their right to life, and liberty, and if you are such a soul, please, stand up and be counted. 70 billion animals are forcibly confined, and being tortured and killed, because those that will not go against the lowest common denominator, sit by and watch. if you come forward, others will too. and many have done so, already. veganism is the fastest growing movement and given half a chance. VEGANS WILL USHER IN THE PEACE WE ALL WANT."

http://www.facebook.com/......916665438/

NOname
| NOname explică:

"YOUR SUBSTANCE OF CHOICE IS KILLING OTHERS BECAUSE OF YOUR ADDICTION and therefore it is not a "personal" choice and it harms other humans, too. as eating meat and dairy uses so much of our resources, it has many people wanting for food and water. your choices have consequences. choosing vegan means you are THINKING OF THOSE YOU MAY HARM, AND CHOOSING TO HARM NONE."

http://www.facebook.com/......266664903/

NOname
| NOname explică:

"WHEN WE SEE ANIMALS THAT HAVE BEEN PART OF OUR FAMILIES KILLED FOR FUR OR MEAT, we react in immediate disgust. now we must extend this compassion to all animals including those in farms. please sign below, for the cats and dogs of USA, China and Korea. we must all stop buying the products that come from their pain and suffering in our own countries, wherever we live, whatever the animal...THEY ARE ALL FRIENDS, NOT COMMODITIES."

http://www.facebook.com/......476666582/

NOname
| NOname explică:

"WE MUST TEACH THE CHILDREN COMPASSION AND CARE FOR ALL BEINGS and not teach them machines are what needs our attention. our world will be a kinder and gentler place, if we see all beings as our family. learn to reconnect with nature and all living beings yourself, then teach your children, well. LOVE AND FREEDOM, FOR ALL!"

http://www.facebook.com/......553372541/

NOname
| NOname explică:

"THE EYES NEVER LIE, AND THESE EYES SHOW A TERRIFIED SOUL, that is powerless to what is about to befall them. all because we pay these hitmen to kill for us, when we eat meat or dairy and/or wear fur or leather. look into this eye and tell them, their pain does not matter. if you can, you have lost your own soul, and are a slave to the Meatrix. FREE YOURSELF TO LIBERATE THESE VICTIMS OF YOUR APPETITES."

http://www.facebook.com/......469816116/

NOname
| NOname explică:

"A MOTHER & CHILD THAT LOVE THIS MUCH, SHOULD BE LEFT IN PEACE, to pursue their idea of happiness and to live and love, freely. we are not the only species living on this planet. we just act like we are. we must stop invading their homes, harming them and separating families, for our misguided ideas of "entertainment", "conservation" or "food". IT WAS THEIR PLANET, BEFORE WE ARRIVED!"

http://www.facebook.com/......576483272/